A Hypothetical DSCR Loan Scenario Based Upon A Real Property And A Qualified Buyer 

(5-Year Breakdown)

What the Numbers For A Hypothetical DSCR Scenario Could Look Like With Property Management, Taxes, and Conservative Investing. 
Why This Scenario Matters: 
There’s no shortage of bold claims online about real estate investing — fast cash flow, early retirement, and “passive income” with no effort. 
This blog is different. What follows is a Hypothetical DSCR rental scenario using: A modest brand-new home, Professional property management, Conservative rent increases, Modest appreciation, Disciplined investing of only the remaining cash flow, A high-income W-2 investor. No hype. Just math.


Although With This Hypothetical DSCR Loan Scenario Has Favorable Conditions In A Certain Market Area:

Disclaimer:
This scenario is provided for educational and illustrative purposes only. It is a hypothetical example and is not intended to represent a guarantee of profit or specific financial results. Actual results may vary and may be better or worse depending on factors including, but not limited to: market conditions, rental demand, property expenses, interest rates, property management costs, real estate negotiations, and individual financial circumstances. There is no guarantee that any investor will achieve the same or similar results, and investment performance is not guaranteed. This example is not a commitment to lend, not an offer to extend credit, and not a loan approval or pre-approval. All loan programs are subject to credit approval, underwriting guidelines, and lender requirements, which may change without notice.

Prospective investors should consult with their CPA, tax advisor, financial advisor, and real estate professionals before making any investment decisions.



The Property & Loan Setup


This Home Was Available As of 1/30/2026. The Builder Was DR Horton And In This Hypothetical Scenario, We Would Offer A Purchase Price Of $188,900 And Ask For $2,500 To Help With Closing Costs 


  • Purchase price: $188,900

  • Property type: New construction, single-family home

  • Down payment (20%): $37,780

  • Loan type: 30-year fixed DSCR

  • Interest rate / APR: 7.125% / 7.508%

  • Seller concessions: $2,500

  • Total cash to close: $45,713
    (Down payment plus lender fees and closing costs after concessions)

Loan amount: $151,120


Monthly Ownership Costs

ExpenseMonthly
Principal & Interest$1,018.12
Property Taxes$157.42
Insurance$115
HOA$50
Subtotal (before management)$1,340.54

This Is A Screenshot From A Website Called Rentcast Which Will Give You A General Idea Of What A Home Will Rent For Based Upon The Street Address Given



Conservative Rental Income Assumptions


This model assumes slow, steady rent growth, not aggressive projections.

YearMonthly Rent
Year 1$1,950
Year 2$1,975
Year 3$2,000
Year 4$2,025
Year 5$2,050


Property Management 

(The Real Cost of Being Hands-Off)


This investor chooses professional property management.

  • Management fee: 10% of collected rent

YearAnnual Management Cost
Year 1$2,340
Year 2$2,370
Year 3$2,400
Year 4$2,430
Year 5$2,460

Updated Monthly Expenses (Year 1)

  • Base ownership costs: $1,340.54

  • Property management: $195

👉 Total monthly expense:$1,535.54




Net Monthly Cash Flow (Year 1)


  • Rent: $1,950

  • Expenses (including management): $1,535.54

👉 Net cash flow:$414.46 per month

This cash flow is not spent.




How the Cash Flow Is Used


Rather than increasing lifestyle expenses, the investor allocates cash flow conservatively and this is done to be used in case any repairs need to be made on the rental property. Since this is a new home, the builder should issue a 1 year warranty.


Monthly Allocation


  • $300/month → High-Yield Savings Account (3% Interest Gain) 

  • $114.46/month → Stock market investment (8% Interest Gain)

This approach:

  • Builds a true emergency fund

  • Adds diversification outside real estate

  • Maintains liquidity

  • Keeps the model conservative and repeatable



This is for informational purposes only and not tax advice. Everyone's situation is unique. Seek advice from your own tax professional concerning your unique situation.


Investor Profile (Tax Context)


  • Age: 45

  • Filing status: Single

  • W-2 income: $100,000/year

  • Federal marginal tax bracket: ~24%

  • State taxes: Not included (varies by state)



Why Taxes Don’t Destroy This Deal


Rental income is not taxed like W-2 income.

Deductible Expenses Include:

  • Mortgage interest

  • Property taxes

  • Insurance

  • HOA dues

  • Property management fees

  • Depreciation

Depreciation (Estimated)


  • Depreciable value: ~$151,120

  • Annual depreciation: ≈ $5,495


Result (Simplified)

After deductions and depreciation, the rental income is close to tax-neutral, even though it produces positive cash flow.

This is one reason high-income earners often use real estate as a long-term wealth and tax-efficiency tool.

(Always consult a tax professional.)



Property Growth & Equity After 5 Years


  • Annual appreciation: 2.125%

Estimated value after 5 years: ≈ $210,300
Remaining loan balance: ≈ $141,000

👉 Equity after 5 years:≈ $69,300




Investment Account Growth (5 Years)


📈 Stock Market Portfolio

  • Initial investment: $114.46

  • Monthly contribution: $114.46

  • Assumed return: 8% annually

Total contributions: ≈ $6,982
Estimated value after 5 years:≈ $8,500



🏦 High-Yield Savings Account


  • Monthly contribution: $300

  • Interest rate: 3%

Estimated value after 5 years:≈ $19,500

This is fully liquid capital.



Total Net Worth After 5 Years


AssetValue
Home Equity≈ $69,300
Stock Portfolio≈ $8,500
Emergency Savings≈ $19,500
Total Net Worth≈ $97,300


What This Scenario Actually Shows


This investor:

  • Bought one modest new construction rental

  • Used professional property management

  • Took zero shortcuts

  • Made conservative assumptions

  • Invested only the remaining cash flow

  • Never relied on appreciation alone


And still built nearly $100,000 in net worth in five years — while maintaining a full-time W-2 income.



Final Thought


This is what boring, disciplined investing looks like.

Not flashy.
Not viral.
But repeatable.

Wealth isn’t built by chasing perfect deals — it’s built by executing solid ones consistently.



Important Disclaimer

This example is for educational purposes only. Returns, tax outcomes, and expenses vary by individual situation. Always consult your CPA, tax advisor, or financial professional.


Mark Crunk | NMLS #2267612 | Barrett Financial Group, L.L.C. | NMLS #181106 | 275 E Rivulon Blvd, Suite 200, Gilbert, AZ

85297 | AK AK181106 | CO | MO | NC B-203722 | Equal Housing Opportunity | This is not a commitment to lend. All loans are

subject to credit approval. | nmlsconsumeraccess.org/EntityDetails.aspx/COMPANY/181106